Our friend OiYan Poon weighs in on the latest round of media hype surrounding Asian Americans and college admissions. This post was originally published over at Hyphen.
'Tis the season again: of holiday parties, excessive consumerism... and media hype over whether elite colleges and universities discriminate against Asian Americans in their undergraduate admissions process. This annual tradition may have begun in 2006 with Jian Li's well-publicized lawsuit against Princeton. Li, who was a student at Yale and later transferred to Harvard, alleged that Princeton exhibited an anti-Asian admissions bias, in rejecting him despite his high test scores and GPA.
Almost a year ago, the media exploded with debates over the Tiger Mom's memoir on extreme parenting. Among Amy Chua's spurious arguments was the suggestion that her brand of childrearing helped explain why Asian Americans are highly represented, if not overrepresented, amongst undergraduates at Ivy League schools and similarly selective institutions.
Now, in the early winter of 2011, comes the latest hackneyed news story about how some mixed-race (hapa) Asian American applicants with non-Asian surnames are avoiding identification with their Asian heritages as a precaution against possible anti-Asian bias at top schools.
Over the last 5 years of this mainstream media-driven discussion, we have learned two things:
